I’m using python-telegram-bot for my project and need to compile a full list of users from a Telegram group where my bot is active. I’ve searched through the documentation but couldn’t find a direct method for this. To try a workaround, I wrote this alternative code:
def fetch_group_users(update, context):
group_id = update.effective_chat.id
users_list = context.bot.get_chat_administrators(group_id)
for user in users_list:
print(user.user.username)
# Register the command handler
dispatcher.add_handler(CommandHandler('listusers', fetch_group_users))
Unfortunately, this code doesn’t do what I need. Am I overlooking something? Any advice or suggestions are welcome!
As someone who’s worked extensively with Telegram bots, I can confirm that obtaining a complete member list isn’t directly possible due to Telegram’s privacy policies. Your current approach only retrieves administrators, not regular members.
A workaround I’ve implemented is using message handlers to track active users over time. This method gradually builds a user database as members interact in the group. Additionally, you could create a /register command that users can voluntarily use to add themselves to your list.
Keep in mind that these methods won’t give you an instant, complete list, but they’re compliant with Telegram’s terms of service and can provide valuable user data over time. It’s a balance between respecting user privacy and gathering necessary information for your bot’s functionality.
I’ve been in your shoes before, and I can tell you that getting a full list of group members isn’t straightforward with python-telegram-bot due to Telegram’s privacy policies. Your approach with get_chat_administrators() will only fetch admins, not regular members.
Here’s what worked for me: I had to use a combination of event handlers to gradually build a list of active users over time. I set up message handlers to capture user activity and slowly populated my database. It’s not instant, but it’s effective for long-term group management.
Another trick I found useful was encouraging users to interact with a welcome message or a command that registers them. This way, you can build your user list organically as members engage with your bot.
Remember, there’s no perfect solution due to privacy constraints, but these methods can help you gather user data over time without violating Telegram’s terms of service.
yo, i feel ur pain. gettin all users aint easy cuz telegram’s privacy stuff. wat i did was make a /joinlist command. when peeps use it, i add em to my database. not perfect but works ok. also, set up message handlers to catch active users over time. takes a while but u’ll get most folks eventually