Is it possible to combine a custom keyboard with force_reply in Telegram bot API?

Other Questions Telegram bot
1

I’m trying to set up a Telegram bot that uses both a custom keyboard and force_reply. I want the user to see the keyboard options, but I also need the question to be quoted in their reply. Here’s what I’ve tried:

const options = {
  reply_markup: JSON.stringify({
    keyboard: [['Yes', 'No']],
    one_time_keyboard: true,
    resize_keyboard: true,
    force_reply: true
  })
};

The custom keyboard shows up fine, but the force_reply doesn’t seem to work. I know force_reply works on its own, but can it be used together with a custom keyboard? Is there a way to make both features work at the same time? I’m not sure if I’m missing something in the API or if this combination isn’t allowed.

2

hey man, i had the same issue. turns out force_reply and custom keyboards dont play nice together :frowning: maybe try using inline keyboards instead? they’re more flexible and might work better for what ur trying to do. good luck!

3

I’ve encountered this limitation as well. Unfortunately, force_reply and custom keyboards are mutually exclusive in the Telegram Bot API. As an alternative, you could consider implementing a two-step process: first, present the custom keyboard for selection, then follow up with a separate message using force_reply to quote the user’s response. This approach maintains the functionality you’re aiming for, albeit with a slightly different user experience. Another option, as mentioned, is to explore inline keyboards which offer more flexibility in terms of UI elements and user interactions.

4

From my experience working with Telegram bots, combining force_reply with custom keyboards isn’t directly supported by the API. It’s a common frustration for developers.

One workaround I’ve used is to implement a state machine in your bot’s logic. First, send the custom keyboard. Once the user selects an option, immediately follow up with another message using force_reply. This method maintains the flow you’re after, albeit in two steps.

Another approach is to use inline keyboards instead. They’re more versatile and can often achieve similar functionality to what you’re aiming for with custom keyboards + force_reply.

Remember to handle edge cases, like users ignoring the keyboard or sending unexpected messages. Robust error handling is crucial for a smooth user experience.